Payne Lindsey and team have headed back to Ocilla, Georgia to pick up where the first season of his smash hit true crime podcast left off, and it will all be documented in a one night television special for Oxygen Media. Their investigation lead to the arrest of two men who plead not guilty and are still awaiting trial for the disappearance and murder of Tara Grinstead, but the suspects' legal maneuvering so far proves there are still many questions left unanswered. For the first time, fans of the podcast will get a look at Payne and crew as they show the audience all of the evidence they already found and fit it together with the new pieces emerging from pre-trial transcripts and interviews.

Ted Bundy: American Boogeyman
2021
6.6/10

Dead Man's Folly
1986
6.4/10

Miss Marple: 4.50 from Paddington
1987
7.4/10

The Crash
2026
7.0/10

Nail Bomber: Manhunt
2021
6.5/10

Welcome to the Punch
2013
5.9/10

Gang Related
1997
6.4/10

Voyeur
2017
5.9/10

Belly
1998
6.2/10

Maternal Instinct
2026
7.3/10

Marlowe
1969
6.1/10

Mindcage
2022
5.9/10

Parker
2013
6.1/10

I Am All Girls
2021
6.5/10

H.H. Holmes: America's First Serial Killer
2004
6.2/10

Cult Killer
2024
6.4/10

Why Did You Kill Me?
2021
5.9/10

Walker, Texas Ranger: Trial by Fire
2005
6.4/10

Cleveland Abduction
2015
7.2/10

Con Mum
2025
6.9/10
Dark Land: The Hunt for Wales' Worst Serial Killer
2022
0/10