On October 22nd, 1966, Jenny Sims returned to her home on 641 Muriel Court from a night of babysitting. Upon her return, she found her mother, father, and 12-year-old sister bound, gaged, shot, and stabbed in the back bedroom. That night marked an abrupt transition for the residents of Tallahassee, Florida: door locks were sold out, gun stores were emptied, and people no longer felt safe or trusting of their neighbors. To date, no charges have been pressed for the murder of Helen, Robert, and Joy Sims. The 50-year investigation has uncovered a series of interesting suspects, none of which have been formally cleared. This film covers all five, including a never-before-seen police interview with one suspect from 1987, and an interview with her ex-husband filmed in the summer of 2016.

The Crash
2026
6.8/10

A Toxic Love Story
2026
6.4/10

The Menendez Brothers
2024
7.2/10

My Mom Jayne
2025
8.0/10

The Cheshire Murders
2013
6.5/10

Maternal Instinct
2026
7.2/10

Ted Bundy: Mind of a Monster
2019
7.6/10

Tales of the Grim Sleeper
2014
6.3/10

Why Did You Kill Me?
2021
5.9/10

Come See Me in the Good Light
2025
7.1/10

Murder to Mercy: The Cyntoia Brown Story
2020
6.9/10

Voyeur
2017
5.9/10

Avatar: The Deep Dive - A Special Edition of 20/20
2022
7.2/10

Stolen: Heist of the Century
2025
7.1/10

Long Shot
2017
7.2/10

28 Up
1985
7.5/10

Out of Thin Air
2017
5.9/10

Anna Nicole Smith: You Don't Know Me
2023
6.1/10

Black Sheep
2018
7.2/10

Girl in the Picture
2022
7.1/10
Cameras A.D.
2023
0/10