The disappearance of Jill (Lonna Cottrell), in the first film, prompts her sister, stepmother and best friend to go to the island in search of her. However, all that happened in the first film is not entirely as it seemed.

Sweetheart
2019
6.4/10

Silver Bullet
1985
6.7/10

Monster Island
2025
6.1/10

April Fool's Day
1986
6.1/10

The Boogeyman
2023
6.4/10

The Blob
1958
6.2/10

Splinter
2008
6.2/10

Don't Be Afraid of the Dark
2010
5.8/10

The Others
2001
7.6/10

Jeepers Creepers
2001
6.5/10

Creature from the Black Lagoon
1954
6.8/10

Dolly
2026
5.8/10

King Kong
1933
7.6/10

Shivers
1975
6.4/10

Into the Deep
2025
5.8/10

Hungry
2026
7.2/10

Primate
2026
6.5/10

Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter
1984
6.1/10

Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island
1998
7.7/10

American Gothic
1987
5.9/10
It Lives Again
1978
5.5/10